Honey vs Agave: Which Sweetener Is Better?

Honey vs agave – a honey jar next to an agave plant and syrup

Honey and agave syrup are both popular natural-looking sweeteners — but they’re quite different. Here’s how honey vs agave compare on taste, nutrition, blood sugar and cooking, so you can choose the right one.

What is agave syrup?

Agave syrup (often called agave nectar) is made from the sap or juice of the agave plant, mainly in Mexico. The juice is heated or treated with enzymes to break its carbohydrates into sugars, then filtered and concentrated into syrup. Honey, by contrast, is made by bees from flower nectar and can be eaten simply strained — see how do bees make honey?

Honey vs agave at a glance

HoneyAgave syrup
Calories (1 tbsp)About 64About 60
Main sugarsFructose ~38%, glucose ~31%Mostly fructose (often 70–90%)
Glycemic indexAround 50–60 (varies)Low, around 15–30
ProcessingCan be raw, just strainedAlways processed
FlavourVaries by flower — floral to maltyNeutral, very sweet
Vegan?NoYes
ExtrasSmall amounts of antioxidants, enzymesVery few

Which is healthier?

  • Agave’s low GI comes from its very high fructose content. But large amounts of fructose are processed by the liver, and eating a lot of added fructose is linked to health concerns — so a low GI doesn’t automatically mean healthier.
  • Honey raises blood sugar more quickly, but contains small amounts of antioxidants and natural enzymes, especially in darker and raw honey.
  • Both are added sugars. Health guidelines recommend keeping all free sugars low. See how much honey per day.

Cooking and baking

  • Agave is runnier and dissolves easily in cold drinks.
  • Honey adds more flavour and browns faster in baking — see how to substitute honey for sugar.
  • You can usually swap them 1:1 in drinks and dressings.

Which should you choose?

Browse our natural honey collection, including Sidr honey and Manuka honey. See shipping & returns and our FAQ for order details.

Read more: Honey vs Sugar · Honey vs Maple Syrup · Is Honey Vegan?